AI isn’t killing jobs, it’s changing them. One of the biggest changes is that a growing number of hiring managers are looking for candidates with taste. People who know how to identify quality, set the bar for it, and hold that bar will stand out. If you want to learn more about how to cultivate taste, book a session with me.
Do you walk around with a notebook? I have for most of my career. I’d carry the notebook because, as a journalist, the smallest detail could turn into a big story. I learned later, while studying design, that writing down what you think about the things and ideas you encounter day to day is one of the easiest ways to cultivate taste. Today, taste is one of the most highly sought-after attributes in the job market.
Taste vs. judgment
When I am talking about taste, I’m referring to the ability to discern good quality from bad. Specifically, the Cambridge Dictionary’s definition of taste I am referencing is: “a person's ability to judge and recognize what is good or suitable, especially relating to such matters as art, style, beauty, and behavior”. While taste has largely been reserved for the arts, style, entertainment, and popular culture more broadly, it is increasingly important in other lines of work like programming, finance, and law as AI becomes more widespread. It’s worth noting that taste and judgement are not the same. Taste is “the ability to judge” while judgment is, according to the Cambridge Dictionary, “the ability to form valuable opinions and make good decisions”. My shorthand is that taste is instinct that informs curation on the basis of style and preference while judgment is deliberate and informs decisions and opinions on the basis of data. I cultivate taste by observing the world around me and listening to my intuition. I strengthen my judgment by consuming information, monitoring cause and effect, and surveying others opinions and perspectives. My taste comes from my experiences and how they make me feel. My judgment comes from my education and what it tells me about the world and how it works.
Why taste matters
Fear of AI-related job loss is rational even if there are researchers who project job gains over the medium-to-long term. While a lot of people are taking it as an invitation to transition to entrepreneurship, that way of working isn’t for everyone. If you want to get hired, one of the most important attributes hiring managers are looking for is taste. They want to know if you can tell which model to use when, if the output from a model is good or bad, and whether you know when a task is right for AI and when it’s not. Taste has long been a critical component of value creation, especially for those in leadership. Often, what distinguishes a strong leadership candidate from a weak one is whether they have put in the work to cultivate taste.
The risk of hiring for taste
Taste is fundamentally subjective. It is essentially a form of bias. This makes it difficult to assess prospective hires for taste without slipping into potentially harmful biases. Taste is informed by so many aspects of a person’s lived experience and personal nature. So, it’s important, if you are in the hiring seat, to keep that in mind. The goal is not to hire for the same kind of taste. Instead, you want to hire for a variety of tastes. Hiring a team of people with homogenous taste profiles will make your organization brittle. Say it with me: the data is clear, diverse teams managed well are stronger teams.
How to cultivate taste
I engage in the following practices to cultivate taste:
- Be curious. One of the most important contributors to taste is curiosity. When I say be curious, I specifically mean intentionally going out and learning new things even when it’s uncomfortable. Talk to people who have a different perspective on the world than you do. Embrace opportunities to sit in environments with people you disagree with. Give yourself permission to try new things, fail, and capture the learning. The more threads of curiosity you pull on, and the more time you put into capturing what you experience and learn, the sharper your sense of taste will get.
- Capture what you think about things. I carry a notebook with me and jot down what I think about things – even if the thoughts are banal and unrefined. This week, for example, I went to a film screening. Even in the dark of the theater, I had my notebook out and captured what I thought about the film. I went back to review those notes, and one of the notes inspired this piece.
- Travel. While this one isn’t necessarily accessible to everyone, it is an important ingredient in my ability to cultivate taste. Seeing other parts of the world around me helps me determine what I like and what I don’t across a broader swath of experiences and inputs.
- Consciously interact with algorithms. Algorithms reinforce behaviors and preferences, and they can dull your sense of taste. Taste thrives on diversity of inputs. When you can, I recommend resisting algorithmic choice. However, if you like having algorithms make decisions for you, be conscious of what decisions they make and why. Capture that and understand why you like it. Also, keep a record of what the algorithm is showing you and why it is likely showing you those things.
- Know your values. Do you value honesty and integrity? Do you value empathy and compassion? Do you value authenticity and love? What about learning? It’s important to know what you value and what you don’t, and which values you hold relative to others. For example, do you value integrity over financial security? Do you value bravery over survival? Do you value a good deal over luxury? What about ambition relative to family or novelty versus security? Your values operate as your inner compass; they inform your choices and goals day-to-day. When events or circumstances feel uncertain, your values are what ground you. Your values will almost certainly change multiple times over the course of your life as you experience new things. But keeping track of them intentionally can sharpen your taste.
- Own your preferences. If you really like something, don’t be afraid to share it with others. For example, I really (and I do mean really) like “One Piece”, and I prefer it to all other anime I have seen. I think it’s a brilliant show for a variety of reasons (some of which I capture here). I like it because I value integrity, loyalty, authenticity, and curiosity over power, money, influence, and control. The show celebrates the former while holding a critical lens to the latter. I also prefer spicy foods, mountain settings, dark humor, fluorescent pink, and anything with sparkles. It took me a while to own up to that last one because, for years, I had been told that sparkly things were frivolous and frivolity was a sign of weakness. Experience has taught me those were someone else’s values informing their taste. I don’t hold those values, and my taste is different. That’s okay.
- Adopt hobbies. My two main hobbies are writing and tarot. I don’t practice either as consistently as I would like, but when I do, they make me happy. Tarot sharpens my intuition, and writing sharpens my preferences.
Putting it all together
Here’s how AI and taste meet in my day-to-day life. Every morning, I have an LLM give me a writing prompt. I accept the prompt probably 5% of the time. Most times, I either reject it or modify it significantly. I rejected the prompt in the lead up to writing this piece because I had a better prompt from my personal experiences the night before.
That’s where taste and AI meet.
I instinctively knew the AI made a bad choice, and I rejected it. In our business, I am constantly rejecting and rewriting what I get from AI – especially when it comes to strategic and creative work. My experience has taught me that AI isn’t smarter than I am. It can access, organize, and synthesize more data more quickly, but that’s not the full breadth of intelligence.
AI doesn’t read tarot the way I do. It doesn’t know what it was like to grow up like me or how it felt to hike a glacier in Norway. It has shards of a lot of our collective lived experiences, but it doesn’t have a lived experience unto itself.
That’s why taste matters. You need to know when and how to apply the breadth of your lived experience, preferences, values, and intuition so you can know when to push a model further, reject its outputs, and go it alone. People who know how to do that consistently well will be worth their weight in gold regardless whether they choose to launch their own company or apply to work for someone else’s.
.png)
.png)
.png)