It doesn’t matter how good you are at prompting, your AI marketing email is trash. No, literally, it’s in my trash folder.
Here’s why: your missive is no more unique than the next person using the same AI model. All of you use models trained on the same insanely large data repos, so you enter my inbox with the same subject lines, hooks, and tactics.
There are a lot of tools available to help the rest of us reduce the amount of AI spam we receive. Many of my friends use Proton Mail and Superhuman (though I can’t recommend either because I’ve never used them). I prefer to make filters do the work for me. So, over time, my inbox has learned the pattern of marking AI marketing slop as spam, but every once in a while, a very convincing email gets through.
The case of the imaginary podcast
As a startup CEO in the earliest possible stages of building a company, I’m thirsty for any hint of an opportunity. Marketers know this and use it to prey on me and a growing number of startup founders. They hold out the promise of investment, podcast features, and targeted lead-gen. None of these offers are real. The spam extends to LinkedIn, where I receive a number of invitations to connect with people marketing all manner of services and products, none of which will prove helpful in forwarding our business.
“Emi, it's been a few days since my note about talent agencies for Sublimate.”
Yep, and it will be an infinite number of days longer.
“Emi, I saw that Sublimate trains a private image model on one person and keeps that person in control of it.”
No, you didn’t see anything. Your slop bot scraped it.
“Emi, Have you ever considered hosting your own podcast to build more thought leadership in the digital printing industry?”
No, and your bot is a colossal waste of valuable GPU time.
“Sam and Nick host The Growth Operator, a podcast for Information Technology and Services leaders who talk honestly about how they actually built their firms. Would you be open to joining us as a guest?”
Too bad the podcast doesn’t exist.
The last two almost got me, I’ll be honest. I’ve been looking for ways to authentically spread the word about Sublimate and the consent-first, subject-controlled way in which we’re approaching the design and training of personal, private AI models for human figure generation.
Fight fire with fire
With both of those scam emails, I was able to claw back my dignity with one painfully simple trick: I fed the email into my LLM of choice and asked if it was a scam. The model almost certainly knows because the scammers probably used that very same model to make their slop. The model also has no emotions, so it can dispassionately break down the emotional hooks and other tricks typical of scammy spammy slop.
Even if scammers use different models, the thirst for training data across the AI industry means there’s a lot of overlap, which makes just about any LLM a good poison taste tester (shout out to all of The Apothecary Diaries fans out there).
The other way I know it’s likely a scam is if a reply comes back in negative two seconds. The bot immediately tells on itself; no human writes that fast.
That’s what happened with the last message with the imaginary podcast invite. The speed of the reply tipped me off, so I pushed it to an LLM. The LLM recommended I reply back asking, “Could you send over a link to a couple of recent episodes so I can get a feel for the format before booking time?”
I sent it, and guess what? Radio silence ever since.
If you are tired of wondering whether a marketing email is a legitimate outreach or not, push it over to an LLM. Most of them should be good at spotting most types of scams by now. There’s only so much available training data in the world, so it’s very likely these scams and the unfortunate stories of their victims are in there somewhere.
The practice of using LLMs to discover risk factors in fraudulent emails is getting media coverage and a number of AI-powered scam filters are popping up to help filter marketing slop at scale. So, there are a lot of ways to fight this growing fire with fire of your own. If you really want to upgrade your spam blowtorch, there are guides like this one to help.
Whatever your strategy, good luck, and stay safe out there.
.png)
.png)
.png)